In oligopolistic markets, competition takes on a unique form. Unlike perfectly competitive or monopolistic markets, oligopolies are dominated by a few powerful firms that closely monitor each other’s actions. This interdependence makes collusion an attractive strategy for maximizing profits and controlling the market. The three main types of collusion in oligopoly—tacit, formal, and illegal—help illustrate how firms interact. Real-world examples will show how these forms of collusion operate and why they are so common in industries dominated by a few large players.
Understanding Oligopoly and Collusion
Oligopoly refers to a market structure characterized by a small number of large firms, each of which has significant market power. In such settings, the behavior of one firm directly affects its competitors, leading to an environment of interdependence. This interdependence creates an incentive for firms to collude, either explicitly or implicitly, to reduce competition and secure higher profits. In this way, oligopolies often end up behaving like monopolies, albeit without explicitly merging into one entity.
Collusion can take different forms—some formal, some subtle, and some outright illegal. Below, we break down these types of collusion and how they manifest in oligopolistic markets.
Tacit Collusion
Tacit collusion occurs when firms in an oligopoly coordinate their behavior without explicitly communicating or forming agreements. Essentially, tacit collusion is unspoken cooperation where firms understand that by maintaining similar pricing, production levels, or marketing strategies, they can all benefit without risking explicit legal violations.
Characteristics of Tacit Collusion
Price Matching and Parallel Pricing
Firms engaging in tacit collusion often set prices that are close to or identical to their competitors’ prices. This kind of behavior is prevalent in industries like airlines, where multiple carriers often charge the same prices for similar routes.
Price Leadership
In many cases, one firm acts as a price leader, setting the prices for the entire industry. Other firms follow suit, aligning their prices accordingly. This ensures that prices remain elevated without explicit agreements. For instance, General Motors has historically served as a price leader in the U.S. car industry, with competitors like Ford and Chrysler raising their prices in tandem.
Example of Tacit Collusion
A classic example of tacit collusion can be seen in the airline industry. In the early 2000s, American Airlines announced a baggage fee, and shortly thereafter, Delta, United, and other airlines followed with nearly identical fees. No direct communication occurred between the airlines, but the pattern of behavior was obvious. Through tacit collusion, the airlines collectively adopted similar pricing structures for added services, thereby avoiding destructive price wars that would lower profits.
Formal Collusion
Formal collusion involves explicit agreements between firms to limit competition. Such agreements can take the form of cartels, where members agree on pricing, production levels, or market allocations. While formal collusion is generally illegal in most countries, there are exceptions, particularly in international markets where regulations are less stringent.
Cartels and Agreements
Cartels
A cartel is a group of firms that come together to fix prices, restrict output, or divide up markets to prevent competition. Cartels allow firms to act as a monopoly, maximizing collective profits by controlling the supply and setting high prices. One of the most infamous cartels in the world is OPEC (Organization of Petroleum Exporting Countries), which controls a significant portion of global oil production and uses this control to influence oil prices.
Formal Agreements
In some countries, formal collusion is permitted in specific industries. For example, in certain agricultural sectors, producers may be allowed to enter into formal agreements to regulate supply and stabilize prices.
Real-World Example: OPEC
OPEC is perhaps the best-known example of a formal cartel. Comprising countries that produce the majority of the world’s oil, OPEC has historically used its collective market power to regulate the supply of crude oil and influence global prices. During the 1970s, OPEC members cut production and significantly raised the price of oil, resulting in a dramatic surge in oil revenues for member countries. While OPEC’s control has diminished in recent years due to increased competition from non-OPEC oil producers and renewables, it remains a powerful example of how formal collusion can shape an entire industry.
Illegal Collusion
Illegal collusion involves explicit agreements between firms that violate antitrust laws. Such agreements often pertain to price fixing, market sharing, or bid rigging, and are illegal in most countries because they harm consumers by driving up prices and reducing market choices.
Types of Illegal Collusion
Price Fixing
In price-fixing, firms agree to set prices at a particular level rather than letting them be determined by market forces. This leads to artificially high prices, hurting consumers and limiting their choices.
Market Sharing
Firms may divide the market among themselves geographically or based on customer types, thus eliminating competition in those segments.
Bid Rigging
In bid rigging, firms collude to manipulate the bidding process, often in procurement or public tenders. One firm may deliberately submit a high bid to ensure that another, preselected firm wins the contract.
Examples of Illegal Collusion
One infamous case of illegal collusion occurred in the air cargo industry. In 2006, more than 20 airlines were caught in an international scheme to fix the price of shipping fees for air cargo, resulting in fines totaling over $3 billion. The airlines had secretly agreed on surcharges and pricing mechanisms, effectively manipulating the market at the expense of their customers.
Another notable case involves De Beers, the world’s largest diamond company. De Beers was caught colluding to set diamond prices, using its dominant position to manipulate supply and maintain artificially high prices for decades. Though De Beers faced significant legal challenges, its influence shaped the diamond market until the early 2000s.
Why Collusion Is Tempting for Oligopolies
The temptation for firms in oligopolistic markets to engage in collusion—tacit, formal, or illegal—stems from the unique characteristics of these markets:
Interdependence
The actions of one firm significantly impact the others. Because of this, firms are incentivized to work together, formally or informally, to maximize their collective profits.
High Barriers to Entry
Oligopolistic industries are often characterized by high barriers to entry, which limit the number of competitors. With fewer players, coordinating actions (even implicitly) becomes easier.
Homogeneous Products
In some oligopolistic markets, products are largely homogeneous, which means that price becomes the main competitive factor. To avoid destructive price wars, firms often prefer to coordinate on pricing.
Long-Term Gains
Collusion can be incredibly profitable for firms that manage to avoid detection. By cooperating, firms can effectively act as a monopoly, setting prices well above marginal cost and reaping the benefits.
The Impact of Collusion on Consumers and Markets
The effects of collusion—especially illegal collusion—are generally harmful to consumers and the economy:
Higher Prices
Collusion almost always leads to higher prices. When firms coordinate, they can set prices above the competitive level, which means consumers end up paying more than they would in a truly competitive market.
Reduced Innovation
By eliminating competition, collusion reduces the incentive for firms to innovate. If firms are guaranteed a share of the market and high prices through collusion, they may not invest in improving products or processes.
Market Inefficiencies
Collusion distorts the efficient allocation of resources. Instead of responding to consumer demand and market signals, colluding firms maintain artificially high prices, leading to a deadweight loss in the economy.
How Authorities Combat Collusion
To prevent the negative effects of collusion, governments have put in place antitrust laws designed to promote competition and prohibit collusive behavior. In the United States, laws like the Sherman Act and the Clayton Act are instrumental in fighting collusion. Similarly, in the European Union, strict antitrust regulations have led to substantial fines for companies found engaging in anti-competitive practices.
The Role of Whistleblowers and Technology
In many cases, collusion is uncovered through whistleblower programs that offer immunity or reduced penalties for individuals who provide information about illegal activities. Technological advancements also play a key role, with sophisticated data analytics being used to detect unusual pricing patterns indicative of collusion.
Conclusion
The types of collusion in oligopoly—whether tacit, formal, or illegal—significantly impact oligopolistic markets. They underscore the complexity and interdependence of firms that balance competition with the lure of cooperation. Although collusion can boost profits for firms, it almost always harms consumers and reduces market efficiency.
Recognizing the types of collusion in oligopoly explains why regulators closely monitor oligopolistic industries and enforce antitrust laws. As long as a few firms dominate markets, the temptation to collude will remain, making strong regulatory frameworks essential for protecting consumers and ensuring fair competition.
FAQs:
What is collusion in oligopolistic markets?
Collusion occurs when firms in an oligopoly cooperate, explicitly or implicitly, to reduce competition and maximize profits. This can take the form of tacit understanding, formal agreements, or illegal activities like price fixing.
How does tacit collusion operate?
In tacit collusion, firms coordinate their behavior without direct communication. They may align pricing or production strategies by observing each other’s actions. Examples include price matching and price leadership.
What is formal collusion?
Formal collusion involves explicit agreements between firms, often through cartels. These agreements set prices, restrict output, or divide markets. Cartels like OPEC are well-known examples of formal collusion.
What is illegal collusion?
Illegal collusion includes explicit agreements that violate antitrust laws, such as price fixing, market sharing, or bid rigging. Such practices harm consumers by increasing prices and reducing choices.
Why is collusion common in oligopolies?
Firms in oligopolies are interdependent and face high barriers to entry, making collusion tempting. Coordinating actions helps avoid destructive competition, maintain high prices, and secure long-term profits.
How does collusion impact consumers and markets?
Collusion leads to higher prices, reduced innovation, and market inefficiencies by distorting competition. Consumers face fewer choices and often pay more for goods and services.
How do authorities combat collusion?
Governments enforce antitrust laws, such as the Sherman Act in the U.S., to prevent collusive behavior. Tools like whistleblower programs and data analytics help detect and penalize collusion.
Can tacit collusion be punished?
Tacit collusion is harder to prosecute as it lacks explicit agreements. Regulators focus on identifying patterns of coordinated behavior that harm market competition.
Thanks for reading! Share this with friends and spread the knowledge if you found it helpful.
Happy learning with MASEconomics
